Authorities have been criticized for sending so many loud phone alerts that many people anzi che no longer take them seriously, potentially controllo lives during Hurricane Ida.
The tropical storm has left a devastating trail of destruction across large parts of the US, killing over 60 people since slamming into Louisiana acceso August 29 as a Category 4 hurricane.
Cellphones across New York and New Jersey pulsed with urgent warnings of catastrophic flooding as the fury of Hurricane Ida’s remnants, carrying torrential rains, approached acceso Wednesday.
But experts fear many residents ignored the alerts after suffering ‘warning fatigue’ when they receive a barrage of messages through the night.
one can be sure what role it might have played per mezzo di a tragedy that killed scores of people across the Northeast, including more than two dozen per mezzo di New Jersey and at least 11 per mezzo di New York City – many drowning per mezzo di their basement apartments ora per mezzo di cars trapped per mezzo di submerged roadways.
Authorities have been criticized for sending so many loud phone alerts that many people anzi che no longer take them seriously, potentially controllo lives during Hurricane Ida
Officials issued three warnings as the tropical storm approached New Jersey and New York acceso Wednesday
Felix Delapuente, a neighbor of the couple and child who drowned per mezzo di their basement, shows the flood damage per mezzo di his basement
The tropical storm has left a devastating trail of destruction across large parts of the US, killing over 60 people since slamming into Louisiana acceso August 29 as a Category 4 hurricane
The first alerts of severe weather blared across millions of phones at 8:41pm acceso Wednesday as Hurricane Ida slammed into New York causing heavy damages
The first alerts of severe weather blared across millions of phones at 8:41pm acceso Wednesday when the National Weather Service warned of dangerous flash flooding from the looming storm.
Officials would issue three more alerts, late into the night, urging people to immediately head for higher basso ostinato and to stay out of rising floodwaters.
A barrage of other alerts from a litany of apps lit up phone screens throughout the night – prompting some to wonder if people were just too inundated with information to take the threat seriously.
The weather service acknowledged that per mezzo di the past, alerts were being pushed out too often. There’s been lots of handwringing over how to get more people to heed warnings.
‘It’s either they don’t believe the information that they’sire hearing – they can’t verify it – ora there’s some other reason that is completely out of anybody’s control,’ said Ross Dickman, the meteorologist per mezzo di charge of the National Weather Service per mezzo di New York.
‘It’s up to that individual,’ he said, ‘but I think we need to do more work per mezzo di understanding why people make the decisions that they do when they receive information and help get them to understand the impacts.’
some cases, people tried to flee too late and became trapped by floodwaters gushing so quickly, and with such force, that they could not gara open their doors to escape.
Others might not have fathomed that flash flooding could also transform roadways into raging, impassable streams.
Hurricane Ida caused widespread damage to basement level apartments across New York, including Queens (pictured)
A volunteer works inside the heavily damaged home of the Hossain-Miu family per mezzo di New Jersey after Hurricane Ida made landfall
People flee heavy rain as Hurricane Ida slammed into New York City acceso Wednesday after wreaking havoc across the country
Hurricane Ida flooded streets per mezzo di Bound Brook per mezzo di New Jersey after slamming into the state acceso Wednesday
Last year, the federal weather service revamped its criteria for issuing alerts, mindful that it might have been overusing the Wireless Emergency Alert system, which first went into operation per mezzo di 2012 and now broadcasts urgent warnings to more than 300 million cellular devices.
The weather service established a three-tier system per mezzo di which alerts would only be sent out for the most severe flooding.
Wednesday was the first time it issued an alert for the most catastrophic level for flash floods per mezzo di New York and New Jersey, Dickman said.
The ubiquity of cellphones makes the devices a key tool for urgently informing the public of dangerous weather, including hurricanes and tornadoes.
It is also used for Amber Alerts to enlist the public to help locate missing children. Authorities have also used cellphone alerts to help authorities nab dangerous people, including a terrorist who set chiuso a bomb four years indicatore per mezzo di New York City’s Chelsea district.
Debris covers the yard of a house per mezzo di New Jersey that was damaged by Hurricane Ida overnight acceso Wednesday
Cars were pushed onto of one another overnight acceso Wednesday as Hurricane Ida slammed into New Jersey
Cars per mezzo di the Bronx, New York City, were submerged acceso Thursday morning after heavy winds and strong rains brought by Hurricane Ida
A resident is embraced by her mother after her home was severely damaged when Hurricane Ida slammed into New Jersey acceso Wednesday
New York City now has a million people subscribed to its wireless alert system that informs of a host of developments, including flooding but also disruptions per mezzo di subway and other city services.
‘People drowning per mezzo di their basement apartments, per mezzo di cars and so acceso is not something we typically would ever see per mezzo di New York, ‘said Irwin Redlener, a founding director of the National Center for Disaster Preparedness at Columbia University who says officials have to have plans to accompany warnings.
‘So if we have warnings that we’sire going to see very severe, rapid rainfall with flash flooding,’ he said, ‘what is it that we actually want people to do?
‘Other than advise people it’s going to happen, do we want them to go to shelters? If so, do we have shelters for them to go?’
The city’s alert system, Notify NYC, launched as Hurricane Sandy approached nine years indicatore. The storm killed dozens per mezzo di New York City and caused massive flooding.
‘We do put a lot of thought into when we push that button – and we know the weather service does, as well – because we don’t want to over warn and we want people to take our warning seriously when we when we’sire issuing messaging,’ said Benjamin Krakauer, an adviser to the Office of Emergency Management commissioner.
Servitore images show the Saffron Banquet per mezzo di Manville, New Jersey is surrounded by floodwaters acceso September 2
A home with flood waters leading into the acceso Lester Street is seen acceso September 2, per mezzo di Passaic City, New Jersey
An aerial photo made with a drone shows damage caused by Hurricane Ida per mezzo di Norco, Louisiana. acceso August 31
James Mielke, a gioco stilista who lives per mezzo di downtown Manhattan, found the alerts more aggravating than useful.
‘They sound like somebody just blew a soccer horn per mezzo di your ear,’ he said.
‘It actually got to the point where I Googled it and figured out how to turn chiuso those alerts so I could just, you know, not have a heart attack every time the siren went chiuso acceso my phone,’ Mielke said.
He said he thought he had turned chiuso all the emergency alerts acceso his phone after Tropical Storm Henri blew through two weeks indicatore.
‘This time they weren’t as bad, but a few still got through’.
Henri brought lots of rain and fury but very little loss of life. That might have prompted complacency, said Jeannette Sutton, a disaster and risk expert specializing per mezzo di communication at the University of Albany.
‘So they got a message last week that said it’s really really bad and then nothing happened. And then this week they get a message that’s really really bad — do they take it seriously?’ Sutton asked.
That’s a question acceso the minds of weather and public safety officials, she said, adding that the seemingly simple act of pushing out alerts is actually complicated.
‘We have been thinking about alerts and warnings since the 1950s, and how to increase their effectiveness, and thinking about how to help people make really good decisions when they’sire faced with life-threatening situations,’ she said.
Houses and businesses are seen damaged acceso September 2 after the town and barrier island of Grand Isle was left devastated by Hurricane Ida
A pick-up truck drives through a flooded River Drive as gabinetto gushes out of a man hole acceso September 2, per mezzo di Passaic City, New Jersey
Flood waters from heavy rain associated with Ida enter Sunflower Organic Cleaners per mezzo di Passaic, New Jersey acceso September 2